Blog

2026.11.10

Pallet Lift and Locate Station Selection: RFP and Acceptance Guide

Pallet Lift and Locate Station Selection: RFP and Acceptance Guide

Selecting a pallet lift and locate station requires more than comparing a repeatability figure. The conveyor stop, locating surfaces, workpiece carrier, fixture, machine datum and control sequence form one system. This guide helps engineering, maintenance and procurement teams in Thailand specify a station, compare quotations, and accept it at FAT and SAT. Here “pallet” means the workpiece carrier used in assembly or inspection, not a wooden logistics pallet. Loads, safety and tolerances for a logistics pallet are different.

Define what the positioning station must do

A conveyor delivers the carrier near a process. A stopper arrests it; a lift and locate mechanism can then raise it off the conveying surface and seat its datum features. Stopping, lifting, constraining X/Y/Z and resisting rotation are separate functions. An RFP must say which functions the station supplies and which remain with the fixture or machine. The real outcome is repeatable workpiece position at the process, not simply a repeatable location of an empty carrier.

A camera may only need the part inside its field of view. Press fitting, fastening, contact measurement and precision assembly can require positional control and stiffness under force. Robot vision correction is a valid competing concept, but it cannot create a mechanical reaction path for a pressing operation. Conversely, putting a high precision lift at every stop may add cost without improving the process. Mark the stations that need location and those that need stopping only on a line diagram. Include merges, diverts, buffers, manual access and reject paths. See our guides to pallet conveyor stoppers and chain conveyor selection for adjacent decisions.

Pallet Lift and Locate Station Selection: RFP and Acceptance Guide - figure 1

Separate conveyor stopping accuracy from process location

Conveyor tracking, rail clearance, wear, impact and carrier variation all affect a moving pallet. A station that locates the carrier on fixed datums after lifting it has a different error chain from one that processes it while it remains on the belt or chain. Specify whether the pallet touches the conveyor during measurement, where process forces go, and whether the measured point is on the carrier or the workpiece. A module’s published repeatability cannot automatically be read as the completed line’s workpiece accuracy.

Test more than repeated cycles of one perfect carrier. Include several pallets, workpieces and product variants; empty and maximum load; cold start and sustained operation; before and after cleaning. Report same-pallet repeatability, between-pallet variation and variation after removing and replacing the workpiece separately. That separation tells the team whether to adjust the locating unit, carrier or fixture.

Freeze carrier and process conditions before requesting prices

Give suppliers drawings of the carrier outline, underside, datum bores or sockets, centre of gravity, fixture height and maximum mass. Include the carrier, workpiece, fixture, clamps and planned options in the load. An eccentric load may change guide forces even when its total mass is unchanged. Show the smallest and largest variants; interference often occurs at the range limits.

For each datum feature, specify position, tolerance, chamfer, wear replacement and exposure to swarf, oil or wash water. Define the support points, required lift height and clearances to tooling. Decide whether the carrier will follow a supplier’s standard design or whether an existing carrier must be retained. For a retrofit, measure physical carriers: old drawings may not describe wear, deformation or past modifications.

Set location requirements by axis: X, Y, Z, yaw and, if relevant, roll and pitch. Repeatability and absolute alignment are different. A carrier can return to the same place while being offset from the robot or machine coordinate frame. State measurement resolution, sample size, measuring points, temperature, load and pass/fail rule. There is no universal acceptable millimetre value; it comes from the process tolerance and its error budget.

Break down cycle time into station states

“One part every 30 seconds” does not tell a supplier how much time is available for location. Break the cycle into approach, stop, presence confirmation, lift, seated confirmation, process permission, processing, lower, release and exit. Define which steps can overlap and where the next carrier waits. A fast actuator cannot cure a full downstream buffer.

Increasing approach speed can increase stop impact and wear at the pallet datum. Observe real carriers at real speed, and adjust conveyor speed, stopper damping and spacing together. Measure time to stable seating, rather than quoting only the actuator’s shortest stroke time. Specify how the station handles a pallet that is still rocking after stopping.

Read manufacturer data as product specific evidence

Published product information helps shortlist concepts, but each value belongs to a named product and stated conditions. Confirm the current variant and drawing with the supplier before purchase.

Primary sourceWhat the source statesWhat to confirm in the RFP
FlexLink Locating Modules documentationPneumatic stop, proximity sensing, wedge and V ruler; location accuracy within ±0.1 mm for the documented moduleCompatible pallets, optional sensing, pneumatic scope and workpiece result
Dorner 2200 Precision Move Lift and LocateA lift and locate module in that pallet systemCurrent variant, carrier size, mounting space and controls
mk Versamove plus PE 2010The PE 2010 locates in X/Y/Z, uses pneumatic lifting, lists ±0.1 mm repeatability and a 40 mm cylinder stroke; Versamove plus lists up to 100 kg per palletApplicability to the quoted variant, fixture mass and selected carrier
Bosch Rexroth TS 2plusA modular family of pallet transfer, positioning and control equipmentExact positioning module, its capacity and integration with existing parts

FlexLink’s figure is not a guarantee for another product or for a complete factory line. The mk figure belongs to PE 2010. The TS 2plus family covers different modules; performance published for one high speed transport section must not be assigned to a separate locating unit. Dorner’s product page does not by itself establish a guaranteed precision for a proposed station; request the current specification and agreed acceptance method.

Stopping, locating and transverse transfer must also stay distinct in the comparison. A corner transfer raises a carrier to change direction; that does not prove it can seat the process datum to the required tolerance. Require drawings showing direction of travel, datum faces, supports, stopper, sensors, lift travel and workpiece orientation.

Pneumatic versus electric drive depends on more than actuator price. Check existing air pressure and quality, piping distance, leakage maintenance, failure position, electrical capacity, cabinet space and local skills. A straightforward two-position stroke can suit pneumatics. Multiple heights or a configurable motion profile may favour electric actuation if a suitable product and safety design exist. Do not infer that every module in a manufacturer’s product family has an electric variant.

Allocate the accuracy budget across the entire process

The relevant error is between tool and workpiece. Draw a chain from station datum through pallet socket, carrier plate, fixture, part seating, machine installation and thermal or force-related displacement. Identify which contributors are systematic offsets and which vary from cycle to cycle. Simply adding catalogue figures is not a complete uncertainty analysis, but listing contributors prevents the team from assigning the whole process tolerance to one purchased module.

For illustration only, if a process needs ±0.2 mm workpiece position and a candidate module advertises ±0.1 mm repeatability, the remaining ±0.1 mm cannot automatically be assigned to the fixture. Carrier-to-carrier differences, dirt, temperature and measurement uncertainty still exist. These numbers are an example, not a design limit. Define the datum, instrument calibration, fixture clamp and zero point before interpreting an acceptance measurement.

When multiple machines share pallets, record coordinate transforms and the procedure for restoring origins after a stop or component replacement. A station that needs a specialist to realign it after every pallet or part change has a real operating cost. Record the adjustment steps and responsible party in the handover package.

Pallet Lift and Locate Station Selection: RFP and Acceptance Guide - figure 2

Write an RFP that suppliers can answer on the same basis

Start with an observable problem: recaptures caused by inconsistent camera position, manual correction before a press, or lost time from failed seating. Link each current value to a target and a test method. “High accuracy” is too vague to evaluate. Supply drawing revisions and dates, and require suppliers to mark assumptions and exclusions explicitly.

RFP itemFactory inputSupplier response
LoadCarrier, fixture and workpiece drawings; mass, centre of gravity and variantsSupported envelope and exclusions
ConveyorMedia, speed, stop point and buffersConnection, stopper and flow limits
LocationDatums, axis tolerances and loaded test conditionsMechanism, test method and guarantee scope
CycleStates from arrival to exitTime by state and abnormal behaviour
UtilitiesAir, power, network and space constraintsConsumption, acceptable variation and connection points
Safety and serviceAccess, jam recovery, cleaning and replacementInterlocks, procedures and consumables
AcceptanceFAT/SAT samples, points and pass ruleTest sheets, instruments and correction plan

If fixture mass or the carrier datum changes after award, the lift, guides, stopper and sensors may need reselection. Compare all quotations on one scope sheet. “Existing conveyor modification excluded,” “carrier machining by customer,” and “guarding supplied by others” can move the actual project price far beyond the initial unit price.

Define control interfaces as states

“Ready” and “Complete” bits alone do not explain recovery. Draw the sequence for arrival, stop, raised position, seated confirmation, process permission, process complete, lowered position, stopper release and departure. Decide how the PLC responds to sensor disagreement, low air, power loss, emergency stop, skewed carrier or debris in a socket. Preserve process-complete information so an automatic restart cannot process the same part twice.

If traceability is required, associate carrier ID, start and finish time, result, retry and manual release. RFID or a code reader is an additional requirement, not an automatic function of every locating unit. Specify where identification occurs and what happens when a read fails or a carrier returns to the station.

Compare the complete installed cost

Include carrier modifications, fixtures, stoppers, sensors, pneumatics, PLC changes, panels, guards, installation, commissioning, spare parts, training and production downtime. For a retrofit, plan the survey, shutdown window and temporary operating method. Record currency, tax, shipping, warranty and the actual local service contact. Ask for part numbers and a supply route for critical replacement items rather than relying on an unqualified stock claim.

Locating pins, sockets, support faces, stopper dampers and sensor brackets require inspection. Define measurement points, replacement thresholds and readjustment steps. Check whether clearing a jam requires tools or entry through a guard. For TCO, compare the same output and service life, including initial price, energy or compressed air, consumables, maintenance hours, downtime and flexibility. Treat unmeasured failure rates and projected savings as scenarios. If rework reduction is a claimed benefit, first measure current recaptures, manual corrections, rejects and stops.

Compare the conditions that make each proposal work. One concept may need machined sockets and periodic replacement; another may retain carriers but require vision correction. Put those costs, unreadable variants and changeover effort on the same table. Separate mandatory outcomes, such as safe stop and workpiece position, from preferences for a particular actuator or brand. Evaluate technical feasibility before commercial ranking. An inexpensive but untestable proposal is not a valid purchase option; an expensive over-specified proposal also needs a demonstrated process benefit.

Verify the station at FAT and on the real line at SAT

FAT checks mechanics, controls and baseline performance at the supplier. SAT checks utilities, upstream and downstream equipment, people and real workpieces at the Thai site. If actual carriers cannot be taken to FAT, record substitute tooling and test limits, and carry missing tests into SAT. A good supplier demo does not reproduce local conveyor height, worn pallets, pressure variation and vibration.

Combine empty, normal and maximum loads with several carriers and variants. Record mean location, spread, worst deviation and failed seating. Agree the sample count and pass/fail rule in the RFP. A passing ten-cycle average can conceal occasional large errors. Investigate outliers before deleting them, and verify that failed seating is detected safely.

Measure throughput under normal mixed production and buffer conditions, not only the fastest isolated cycle. Define what constitutes a stop and how planned pauses count. Safely simulate missing and double pallets, skew, low pressure during lift, incomplete lowering, contradictory sensors, emergency stop and power restoration. Agree how the system recovers without double processing or unexpected movement.

Pallet Lift and Locate Station Selection: RFP and Acceptance Guide - figure 3

The acceptance sheet should contain requirement ID, test method, instrument, site, raw data, result, responsible person, date, drawing revision and corrective action. A provisional acceptance needs explicit operating limits, deadlines, retest method and commercial terms. Hand over schematics, parts list, sensor map, PLC backup, parameters, replacement procedure, origin recovery and alarm history. Provide recovery instructions in a language the people who actually maintain the Thai line can use.

Keep time-series measurements linked to carrier IDs. A problem limited to one pallet points toward its datum; a common warm-up drift suggests installation or thermal effects; random failures may point to dirt or detection. Capture air pressure, alarms and interventions alongside position data. This evidence speeds joint fault finding after commissioning.

Use five decision gates during implementation

First confirm the process problem and rule out fixture, illumination, tool or upstream causes. Second freeze carrier design and the error budget. Third compare multiple concepts against the same RFP and lifecycle conditions. Fourth test the supplied module and controls at FAT. Fifth verify the actual process at SAT. Each gate makes a decision: if a stopper and simple guides suffice, omit the lift; if fixture wear is the root cause, a new lift alone will not solve it.

After start-up, trend failed seating, retries, manual intervention and readjustment by carrier, variant, shift and station. Use these records to decide whether wear, debris, sensing or supply variation needs maintenance attention. Standard modules reduce design work on some mechanical elements, but workpiece datums, interfaces, recovery and acceptance remain project specific.

Include engineering changes and production control in the RFP

Control changes against both carrier and process drawings

The workpiece, fixture, carrier and conveyor speed can change after the locating station is installed. A small change to datum bore position, carrier mass, centre of gravity or pressing force may move the application outside the original operating envelope. A change request should identify not just the new part but which drawing revision and acceptance test need review. Two workpieces with the same outline can have different centres of gravity and produce different tilt during lifting or impact at the stop. A lighter fixture can still change support reactions when its force application point moves.

Maintain a change table showing affected variants; mass and centre of gravity before and after; datum bore and support dimensions; conveyor speed; cycle target; sensor position; PLC version; and test evidence. Record the reason when no new test is judged necessary. “It fits on the machine” does not prove full seating or acceptable long term wear. After machining a carrier socket, inspect its dimensions and the actual seated workpiece position. If the station and pallet come from separate vendors, verify that both drawings use the same datum definition.

Define the approval path for a new product variant. Engineering checks the fixture drawing, maintenance checks load and access, quality checks the measurement method, and production trials changeover. One department’s observation that the machine ran once is insufficient. A small trial should include repeated changes between pallets and retain the ID of every carrier involved in a fault.

Combine cycle counts and position data for preventive maintenance

Calendar-based inspection alone hides the effect of busy periods. Trend actuator cycles, pallet passages, abnormal stops, failed seating and retries together. Attach cycle counts to inspection records for pins, sockets, support faces and stopper dampers. Do not replace parts on a trend alone: verify actual dimensions and process position. A spare-part replacement plan must include time to restore the datum and remeasure it.

Standardize first response to a seating fault. Bring the station into a safe state; inspect carrier and station datums for debris; then check air pressure or electric actuator state, sensor mounting and stopper damping. Adjusting a locating pin simply to silence an alarm can worsen all other pallets if the problem belongs to one carrier. Save pre-adjustment settings and measurements, then validate several representative carriers after the change.

The spare list should name the manufacturer part number, drawing location, allowed alternatives and post-replacement checks. Decide during design whether a pin and socket must be changed as a pair. After replacing a sensor, verify that empty, loaded, skewed and incompletely seated pallets are distinguished correctly. Record photos and measurement points so recovery does not depend on one technician’s memory.

Measure intervention time as well as reject rate

A lower reject rate is not a complete success if operators now keep quality acceptable through frequent resets. Compare before and after using the same definitions for recaptures, manual corrections, failed seating, stops, recovery minutes, scrap and rework. Separate product mix and production volume before interpreting changes. If improvement is absent, inspect supply orientation, fixtures, upstream and downstream waiting, and sensor criteria before concluding that the locating unit lacks capability.

Share event records with the supplier: carrier ID, time, alarm, position measurement and recovery action. A fault that occurs just after a stop suggests different causes from one that appears after a warm continuous run. Record setting changes and results on both sides of the change. Include PLC event capture and a useful maintenance display in the original RFP so improvement can continue after acceptance.

Frequently asked questions

What repeatability should a pallet lift and locate station have?

Derive it from the allowed tool-to-workpiece error, other contributors and measurement uncertainty. Published ±0.1 mm figures for the cited FlexLink module and mk PE 2010 are product-specific statements, not blanket guarantees for all carriers or complete lines.

Can a lift and locate module be retrofitted to a chain conveyor?

Possibly. Measure rail geometry, pallet underside, stop space, lift clearance, load, utilities and guarding. If existing carriers lack suitable locating features, they may need modification. The integration remains project specific even if the module is standard.

Should we choose mechanical location or vision correction?

Choose by required position and stiffness. Vision can measure and compensate for a visible workpiece offset but cannot replace a mechanical reaction path for a press. Mechanical location does not remove variation in how the workpiece sits in its fixture. A combined design should assign each error to one method.

Is FAT enough for acceptance?

No. SAT verifies the real site, signals, carrier condition, air supply, recovery access and sustained flow. Any FAT test performed with substitute equipment remains open until its SAT counterpart passes.

What is the minimum RFP package?

Provide carrier, fixture and part drawings and masses; a line diagram; cycle target; axis tolerances; utilities; state and fault sequences; and FAT/SAT methods. If some data are unknown, list the owner and due date, and separate budgetary from binding quotations.

Conclusion

Pallet lift and locate station selection is a system design decision linking carrier, conveyor, fixture, controls, safety and maintenance. Define the required position at the workpiece, align quotation assumptions in an RFP, verify the module at FAT, and prove the process on the real line at SAT. Specify how the station will retain its capability after handover.

If your carrier drawings or position-loss records are still incomplete, contact TOMAS TECH. We can help a Thailand factory identify the measurements and retrofit boundaries needed for a useful RFP.

Primary references